Author Topic: Raksha Bandhan HAS No Place in Sikhism (Read 7457 times)

_FaTeH_ · « **on:** August 13, 2011, 03:31:40 PM »

1.Why would a Khalsa Kaur ever need anyone’s protection when they have the power within them to defend themselves? That is why if the Singh was given a Kirpan, so was a Kaur granted the same. So Rakhrhi Gives Secondrate status to the women.

2.what of those who have no brothers? Who will protect them? What of those who have no sisters, who will pray for their long life and wellbeing? It’s all out of logic for Sikhs

3.A thread is just an illusion

4.ignorantly been accepted in Sikh culture.

5. The Guru, who rejected the spiritual thread that the Hindu Brahmins consider makes them connected to God, in the midst of all the learned Pandits, Brahmins and his own father, would that same Guru accept the far more earthy thread called a ‘rakhi’?

Please friend donot get me wrong but i was confuse about that so i found that on sikhi wedsite u can read aswel click that link

http://www.sikhiwiki.org/index.php/Raksha_Bandhan

AGER SISTER NE BROTHER NU APNI RAKHA KARAN LAYI KUJ DAINA TA TALWAAR DE DE APNE VEER NU AS A GIFT IK DHAAGE NE KI KARNA AND SISTER CAN PRAY FOR HIS BROTHER HAPPINESS EVERYDAY :D:

Punjabi Janta Forums - Janta Di Pasand · « **on:** August 13, 2011, 03:31:40 PM »

°◆SáŅj◆° · « **Reply #1 on:** August 13, 2011, 08:47:15 PM »

Hanji eho jya similar article parreya si main last year
& os article ch v eho jeha he kuch likheya si ke
Sikhism/Guru Granth Sahib ch rakhri nahi manayi jandi

par i think har ek di apni apni belief hundi a
for example
*FOR ME*
mera bro nahi haiga koi te nah he mainu es festival te yakeen haiga; i believe ke bro chahe 7 samundar paar beitha
hove te rakhsa meri kiven karega je ajj he koi prob aa jaye
on the other hand
my sis believes in this festiveal & does tie a rakhi thread to my cuzin's wrist
*i think har ek di apni apni choice hundi a & different point of views hunde a

*Very informative thread Fateh
thanx for sharin :)

Jatt Yamla · « **Reply #2 on:** August 13, 2011, 08:59:09 PM »

gotta agree i see no purpos as well..

Deleted User · « **Reply #3 on:** August 13, 2011, 09:05:04 PM »

bhara ta mera v nai koi hega bt menu rakhria te bhut yakeen aa

Jhanda_Amli · « **Reply #4 on:** August 13, 2011, 10:38:03 PM »

Rakhri da din - Bebe nanaki da dil udass se, ke saree apde veera nu rakhri bande ne... kash guru nanak we ghar hunde teh bebe nanki we eh ritual kar sakde... babba janni jann... mardanee nu kehan lagge ke ajj ghar jann maan karda aa... Guru nanak apde yatra wich chad ke ayye ke oh apde bhen nanki nu mil sakhan... teh ohna ne rakhri de reet we nibayiee...

- Bhen bhraa de pyaar nu we tharam de naam teh phristh karee janna.. rakhri teh naam de .. teh ek tagga aa.. oh teh pyaar aa jehra bhen bhar nu kol kich launda hai - jenna nu pyaar aa oh es din jithe hon milan nu tras de ne... je father day rakh leya, mother day rakh leya.. teh sister day nu ke problem aa... teh ohnu tharam de naam teh badnam karna - Bhut mari gal aa!!

baki rahi protection de gal... shadde(century) wich wekho kehre wich rehde oo.. ethe teh kuri nu koi khurr ke wekh lavve ... police walle munda lamiya pa lende ne.. I guess mundiya nu protection chaide aa.... ohna deyia bhena nu nai.. .eh teh ek respect teh pyaar da thorr aa..

Baki mother day teh father day Goriya ne baniya..teh odan "Happy mother day"... "happy father day" karnoo nai hathde..... odde nal koi issue nai.. jehra thohar agge india wich exist karda aa.. odde wich nukas kadde challo .. kyun bhee sister teh brother de rishtey nu appriciate karna paap aa.. aukha :hehe:

s · « **Reply #5 on:** August 13, 2011, 10:56:24 PM »

agree vith j ammli n fatehh...so eda matlab sikha nu kaur n singh v hona chida te vich bhai bhen da pawiter pyaar v hona chidda!!!

ਕਰਮਵੀਰ ਸਿੰਘ · « **Reply #6 on:** August 13, 2011, 11:33:08 PM »

fully agree with jhanda bai :smile:
Dekho ji is tra de tyohara rasma da dharam nal bohta sambandh nai. Gal sari yakeen di e k tuc usnu manana e ya nai. Je mande o ta us gal de hak vich 20 tark de sakde o te je nai mande ta 20 tark nakaar sakde o.
Is dhang nal je dekhiye ta har gal fizool e lagdi e. Apa diwali manaunde aa kyo. Eh vi pehla hindua da e tyohar c par bad vich gwaliar di ghatna is nal jud gayi. Par fir v asi har sal diwali mnaunde a jad k eh ghatna kai sau sal purani ho gayi fir v usnu yaad karde aa. Viah vich kine rasam rivaj ne is hisab nal oh sab v fizool ne. Kine mele lagde ne oh v fizool ne.
So ehna rasma rivaja da sambandh dharam nal ghat te samajik tane bane nal zyada e. Ik dusre prati apnia feelling darshaun te relations vich mithas bharan lai eh sab reet rasma boht role ada kardia ne. Kehen nu rakhdi ik dhaga ki rakhya karu kise di par gal e rishtya vichle pyar di.
Ik var raja salwan ne puran bhagat de hath pair vadh k usnu khooh vich sutwa dita . Boht sme bad utho gorakhnath jogi da tola langhya ta unha pooran di awaz suni. Pooran ne jogi nu sari khani dasi ta jogi ne kachi dor khooh vich latka diti te kiha k je tu sacha e ta ese dor de share upar aja. Te pooran use kachi dor de share upar a gya c.
So kehen nu oh kachi dor c par jogi da te pooran da oh pakka yakeen c.
So is tra de reet rivaj sade samajik rishtya de parteek ne. Je usnu sahi soch nal vishvas nal kariye ta oh meaningfull ne te je nai ta pakhand e.
Dharm vich v eho gal lagu e je dil vich shardha e ta oh bhagti e te je nai fir sab pakhand e jini marzi mala feri jao.
Samaj tantar te dharam vich boht nazuk antar hunda e lod hundi e is antar nu samjhan di k kehda kam samajik rasam e te kehda dharmik pakhand.
Sikh dharam katadpanthi nai e . Guru sahib ne jo sahi c chahe oh kise v dharam da c guru sahib ne us di soch vichar vich hami bhari. Guru granth sahib ji is di misal ne. Dhane bhagat ne pathar vicho rab pa lya. Par sikh dharam vich pathar puja di manahi e par fir v dhane bhagat di bani guru sahib vich darj e. Hun tuc eh swal utha sakde o k ik pathar pujan vale di bani kyo darj kiti gayi. Par dhane bhagat da asal maksad rab nu pauna c usne sache dilo us pathar nu e rab manya te rab nu pa lya. So jo dharam da asal maksad e oh pura hoya zaria chahe koi v c.
Guru sahib ne kise dharam nu mada nai kiha mada kiha ta pakhand nu.
So sanu shardha te pakhand vich antar pehla samjhna chahida te bad vich kise nu justify karna chahida.

Kudrat Kaur · « **Reply #7 on:** August 14, 2011, 12:05:11 AM »

Such a sensible explanation by Jhanda amlji and Karam Singhji...
Thanks to Fateh for initiating so interesting discussion..

EvIL_DhoCThoR · « **Reply #8 on:** August 14, 2011, 12:13:25 AM »

Yup agree with amliiiiiiii uncleeeeeeeeeeee , teohar teohar hai , es ch v religion e politicsss aukha .

Deleted User · « **Reply #9 on:** August 17, 2011, 07:10:38 PM »

raj g tusi hamesha 100 anesachi gal karde o
fateh nu ta nukas kade bina nend ni aundi :hehe:

_FaTeH_ · « **Reply #10 on:** August 18, 2011, 11:24:28 PM »

Quote from: Lado on August 17, 2011, 07:10:38 PM

raj g tusi hamesha 100 anesachi gal karde o
fateh nu ta nukas kade bina nend ni aundi :hehe:

lado read mai read colour naal ki likhiya c topic vich i found tht on sikh wedside so i share with everyone mai kuj maada nhi keh riha rakha bandhan nu ok ida na pange liya kar 50 waar dasiya

_FaTeH_ · « **Reply #11 on:** August 18, 2011, 11:29:57 PM »

Quote from: J.A. on August 13, 2011, 10:38:03 PM

Rakhri da din - Bebe nanaki da dil udass se, ke saree apde veera nu rakhri bande ne... kash guru nanak we ghar hunde teh bebe nanki we eh ritual kar sakde... babba janni jann... mardanee nu kehan lagge ke ajj ghar jann maan karda aa... Guru nanak apde yatra wich chad ke ayye ke oh apde bhen nanki nu mil sakhan... teh ohna ne rakhri de reet we nibayiee...

- Bhen bhraa de pyaar nu we tharam de naam teh phristh karee janna.. rakhri teh naam de .. teh ek tagga aa.. oh teh pyaar aa jehra bhen bhar nu kol kich launda hai - jenna nu pyaar aa oh es din jithe hon milan nu tras de ne... je father day rakh leya, mother day rakh leya.. teh sister day nu ke problem aa... teh ohnu tharam de naam teh badnam karna - Bhut mari gal aa!!

baki rahi protection de gal... shadde(century) wich wekho kehre wich rehde oo.. ethe teh kuri nu koi khurr ke wekh lavve ... police walle munda lamiya pa lende ne.. I guess mundiya nu protection chaide aa.... ohna deyia bhena nu nai.. .eh teh ek respect teh pyaar da thorr aa..

Baki mother day teh father day Goriya ne baniya..teh odan "Happy mother day"... "happy father day" karnoo nai hathde..... odde nal koi issue nai.. jehra thohar agge india wich exist karda aa.. odde wich nukas kadde challo .. kyun bhee sister teh brother de rishtey nu appriciate karna paap aa.. aukha :hehe:

chal theek ha veer tu ager sister day kehke manaan nu kahnda fir mann lainde ha

jhanda ik brother day bhi hona chahida ode vich tu mainu rakhi bandi i will protect u :D:

✿MeHaK✿ · « **Reply #12 on:** August 18, 2011, 11:51:25 PM »

Jehri Rakhan Ponia Bnonde Babe Bakale O ki hunda..

urmysunshine · « **Reply #13 on:** August 19, 2011, 09:07:50 AM »

good stuff...but sareyan de apne apne personal beliefs aa..
mere layi raksha bandhan ik din hunda jad me apne sarey cousins nu individually dasdi aa ke i love them..:)
its a way to keep in touch..kyunki aaj kal sarey apni life ch busy aa..

_FaTeH_ · « **Reply #14 on:** August 19, 2011, 03:07:42 PM »

Quote from: urmysunshine on August 19, 2011, 09:07:50 AM

good stuff...but sareyan de apne apne personal beliefs aa..
mere layi raksha bandhan ik din hunda jad me apne sarey cousins nu individually dasdi aa ke i love them..:)
its a way to keep in touch..kyunki aaj kal sarey apni life ch busy aa..

acha mai apne cousin nu everyweeked utte dasda i love them or any fastival like khalda day ,, guru nanak birthday , guru gobind singh birthday ,new year , hor mere cousin di birthday utte bhi greeting utte likh dinde ha i love u bro/sis :D: etc

_FaTeH_ · « **Reply #15 on:** August 19, 2011, 03:09:07 PM »

Quote from: ★ਮੁਸਕਾਨ★ on August 18, 2011, 11:51:25 PM

Jehri Rakhan Ponia Bnonde Babe Bakale O ki hunda..

ih ki hunda i donot know tu das de ih kiha ya fir isdi histroy kiha link de

urmysunshine · « **Reply #16 on:** August 19, 2011, 09:56:51 PM »

Quote from: _FaTeH_ on August 19, 2011, 03:07:42 PM

acha mai apne cousin nu everyweeked utte dasda i love them or any fastival like khalda day ,, guru nanak birthday , guru gobind singh birthday ,new year , hor mere cousin di birthday utte bhi greeting utte likh dinde ha i love u bro/sis :D: etc

yeah me sarey cousins di gal krdi aa..

different for every1 :happy:

@~ਸ੍ਹੌਕੀਨ кαυя~@ · « **Reply #17 on:** August 02, 2012, 07:29:30 AM »

Quote from: _FaTeH_ on August 13, 2011, 03:31:40 PM

1.Why would a Khalsa Kaur ever need anyone’s protection when they have the power within them to defend themselves? That is why if the Singh was given a Kirpan, so was a Kaur granted the same. So Rakhrhi Gives Secondrate status to the women.

2.what of those who have no brothers? Who will protect them? What of those who have no sisters, who will pray for their long life and wellbeing? It’s all out of logic for Sikhs

3.A thread is just an illusion

4.ignorantly been accepted in Sikh culture.

5. The Guru, who rejected the spiritual thread that the Hindu Brahmins consider makes them connected to God, in the midst of all the learned Pandits, Brahmins and his own father, would that same Guru accept the far more earthy thread called a ‘rakhi’?

Please friend donot get me wrong but i was confuse about that so i found that on sikhi wedsite u can read aswel click that link

http://www.sikhiwiki.org/index.php/Raksha_Bandhan

AGER SISTER NE BROTHER NU APNI RAKHA KARAN LAYI KUJ DAINA TA TALWAAR DE DE APNE VEER NU AS A GIFT IK DHAAGE NE KI KARNA AND SISTER CAN PRAY FOR HIS BROTHER HAPPINESS EVERYDAY :D:

rakhri ta guru nanak dev ji de v bnni c ohna di sister ne,,,,, then hun ki kahuye

Author Topic: Raksha Bandhan HAS No Place in Sikhism (Read 7457 times)

Punjabi Janta Forums - Janta Di Pasand

Related Topics

Who's Online

Recent Posts