Critics Award Winners for Jutti Competition 2012

[Pr€€t]

 phyla menu thora jeha jhatka lgya c dekh ke ankhi ni yeah nu milya award kyoki personaly menu ankhi dia jutia bhut sohnia lagia c nd yeah dia v sohnia aa ede ch koi shaw nahi aa
par bayd vich critical view naal dekhya jawe ta yeah kaur de points jayda bande ne ankhi nalo cz vareity n fitting de mamle ch yeah kol jayda score aa

[Jatt Mullanpuria]

phyla menu thora jeha jhatka lgya c dekh ke ankhi ni yeah nu milya award kyoki personaly menu ankhi dia jutia bhut sohnia lagia c nd yeah dia v sohnia aa ede ch koi shaw nahi aa
par bayd vich critical view naal dekhya jawe ta yeah kaur de points jayda bande ne ankhi nalo cz vareity n fitting de mamle ch yeah kol jayda score aa

next time tu judge banjayi. agli competition ch

[_noXiouS_]

 
 
Why don't you guys post the judging criteria and score by each judge, if possible?! Doubts nikal jange users kolo.
 
 
Everyone else - you guys have to remember the criteria that one has to vote upon rather than the look alone of the shoes.

[Grenade Singh]

Why don't you guys post the judging criteria and score by each judge, if possible?! Doubts nikal jange users kolo.

The judging criteria is posted.

Why not posting all the scores?
Most people don't want to see that some judges rated their shoes as "terrible" or gave a score of 1, etc. The point is to look for a winner that has high scores in all the criteria and no bias of having favorites/friends, so we use average votes from 4 judges. I personally don't want to hurt anybody's feelings, so I'm keeping the scores private. No judge knows what another judge voted. Nobody except I (sorry for that) knows what each person's score is.

Possible flaw
It could be argued that I'm an evil person that may be cheating (I did win the last competition). I will honestly take that criticism, and think that we should appoint 1 more person (picked by the janta) that can double check my math. It could be my enemy, it could be anybody.

Another solution: Participants share their score
I did say that I can share what each participant's score is to them alone. So if the participants feel confident/OK/etc, they can share the scores with all here. And then we can all see who received what in each criteria. Here I'll do the honors:

I feel confident by my scores, so here they are totals:

Totals   Judge 1   Judge 2   Judge 3   Judge 4   
Grenade Singh   28   26   23   24   101

Individual judge scores based on criteria:

User/Criteria   Jutti di fitting [1-5]   Jutti is on feet [1-5]   Complements Feet [1-5]   Color & Style [1-5]   Punjabi Virsa [1-5]   Variety [1-5]   Total (out of 30)

Judge 1
Grenade Singh   5   5   5   4   5   4   28

Judge 2
Grenade Singh   4   4   4   5   5   4   26

Judge 3
Grenade Singh   4   4   4   4   4   3   23

Judge 4
Grenade Singh   4   5   4   3   4   4   24

[Jatt Mullanpuria]

good points made, thats why i asked couple of participants, je tuhanu lagda judging ch kharabi see tan scores request karlo from admin and oh de dainge.
And even je scores naal nahi khush tan feedback leh lawo exactly why ehdan di judging hoyi.  In both cases the participants decided not to pursue it any further lol.
Even few people here that had objections, ranjhana, jaspinder and ek hor banda.. ohna vichon bas ek ne reply kitti and in there he didn't want to go through with it.

[• » ∂єѕι кαυя « •]

sab to kanjus jugde

[҂ ȿḉặᵰɗἷἧäѷїѧҋ↔ᶀɍǐȶĩṧӊ ₰]

The judging criteria is posted.

Why not posting all the scores?
Most people don't want to see that some judges rated their shoes as "terrible" or gave a score of 1, etc. The point is to look for a winner that has high scores in all the criteria and no bias of having favorites/friends, so we use average votes from 4 judges. I personally don't want to hurt anybody's feelings, so I'm keeping the scores private. No judge knows what another judge voted. Nobody except I (sorry for that) knows what each person's score is.

Possible flaw
It could be argued that I'm an evil person that may be cheating (I did win the last competition). I will honestly take that criticism, and think that we should appoint 1 more person (picked by the janta) that can double check my math. It could be my enemy, it could be anybody.

Another solution: Participants share their score
I did say that I can share what each participant's score is to them alone. So if the participants feel confident/OK/etc, they can share the scores with all here. And then we can all see who received what in each criteria. Here I'll do the honors:

I feel confident by my scores, so here they are totals:

Totals   Judge 1   Judge 2   Judge 3   Judge 4   
Grenade Singh   28   26   23   24   101

Individual judge scores based on criteria:

User/Criteria   Jutti di fitting [1-5]   Jutti is on feet [1-5]   Complements Feet [1-5]   Color & Style [1-5]   Punjabi Virsa [1-5]   Variety [1-5]   Total (out of 30)

Judge 1
Grenade Singh   5   5   5   4   5   4   28

Judge 2
Grenade Singh   4   4   4   5   5   4   26

Judge 3
Grenade Singh   4   4   4   4   4   3   23

Judge 4
Grenade Singh   4   5   4   3   4   4   24

You're the one and only judge?  Next time i'm nominating myself to be a judge 

[PrInCeSs oF gOd]

You're the one and only judge?  Next time i'm nominating myself to be a judge 

ahahahaha

...
vese meinu sab fair lagda , yeah deya jhutiyan  cegeya he sohniya sab to